CHI Fellowship · 2026 DH Summer Seed Grant · Michigan State University
خرائط سينمائية مضادة
Formal refusal in Palestinian women’s cinema, and how filmmakers resist, reimagine, and refuse the surveillance gaze
Ayaat Ismail
cinematiccountercartographies.com
شو السؤال؟ The question
“Occupation is total: it enters the film not as a subject but as a condition of the image.”
Elia Suleiman
الفكرة The argument
01
Checkpoints are not passive infrastructure. They are architectures of total surveillance: elevated cameras, panoptic visibility, continuous documentation.
02
Filmmakers document them differently. Jacir, Nabulsi, and Masri make counter-cartographies, cinematic maps that refuse surveillance’s spatial and temporal logic.
03
So the map has to make the claim itself. Counter-mapping works in the same register as the surveillance it answers: location, data, and visualization, used against the grain.
كيف كبر المشروع The funding
Dec 2025
One Leaflet.js map of checkpoints
2025–26 · Phase 1
Learned to code; Visual Analysis Theater; partner outreach
Summer 2026 · Phase 2
Funded my summer labor and five years of the domain, cinematiccountercartographies.com
Fall 2026 →
The digital component of my dissertation, Cinematic Refusals
كيف اشتغلت The process
1
Watch closely
Camera position, angle, editing, ellipsis, sound, offscreen space
2
Locate
Tie the scene to a checkpoint: Qalandiya, Bethlehem, Huwwara
3
Geotag & write
Place it on the map with its formal analysis
4
Link
Map popup to film card and clip to glossary terms
5
Open it up
Community stories and corrections, reviewed before they appear
Hand-built in HTML, CSS, and JavaScript on GitHub · rebuilt from Leaflet.js to Mapbox GL JS
الخريطة Live map
شو بخبّوا المخرجات Formal refusal
| Strategy | What it refuses |
|---|---|
|
Defocusing
3000 Nights, Masri |
The doctor kept out of focus, so medicine becomes carceral hands |
|
Averted angle
The Present, Nabulsi |
The camera stays on Yusef’s face, not the soldier’s gun |
|
Unresolved ending
When I Saw You, Jacir |
We never see whether Tarek crosses |
She does not photograph occupation. She photographs life under it.
ليش اخترت هيك Decisions
Glossary before bibliography
Public readers need the vocabulary (counter-cartography, sumud, ellipsis, repertoire) to enter the analysis.
Palestinian dialect, not MSA
Palestinians are the main audience. It slows the work, and it is the point.
Clips embedded, not hosted
Copyright, and an archive under erasure: many films are out of circulation or destroyed.
Refusing the basemap’s names
Available basemaps use Hebrew place names. Restoring Palestinian names is the next priority.
Seed grant: 3 of 6 films analyzed · map rebuilt in Mapbox · community submissions and Arabic interface added beyond the plan
المرحلة التالتة Phase 3
01 Correct the geotags and restore original Palestinian place names
02 Complete the missing clips, analyses, and data
03 Finish and review the Arabic translation
04 Realign the site with my dissertation’s four embodied modes: endurance, persistence, resistance, survivance
Committee presentation, Fall 2026 · Dissertation defense, Spring 2028
صوتكم كتير مهم. بتقدروا تضيفوا أفلام أو قصص أو حتى مواقف صارت معكم عند الحواجز
Thank you · يسلمو
With gratitude to the CHI Fellowship and the DH Summer Seed Grant
Ayaat Ismail · ismailay@msu.edu